Skip to main content

Analysis of Tomorrow's People: Scene 3

Tomorrow's People: Scene 3

The scene takes place in the schoolyard, highlighting the relationship between the teachers and the students. Despite the headmaster walking around "with a stick in his hand, symbolising authority and discipline, there are instances of student misbehaviour as some students can be heard "shouting and playing" during lessons. The chaotic setting indicates the headmasters's ineffective leadership, as his strict methods fail to control the students. The scene thus mocks the education system by presenting the head of the school as failure.

As the plot develops, the headmaster asserts his authority through shouting and hurling vitriol at the students. The semantic field used by the headmaster such as "fool" and "lecherous bastard" suggests that the school is not a safe environment as it exposes children to verbal, psychological and emotional abuse.

Why is the Scene Brief? 

The whole scene is short. Its length reflects the headmaster's lack of engagement with Miss Jubane. He quickly dismisses her, indicating his unwillingness to communicate effectively.  

Why is the Conversation Choppy?

The conversation between the headmaster and Miss Jubane is tense and disjointed. Miss Jubane feels "not comfortable in front of the head." This suggests that the headmaster is hostile and unapproachable. This choppiness reveals the strained relationship between the staff and leadership.

Themes

Freedom vs. Oppression

The contrast between the students playing and the headmaster's strict discipline highlights the theme of freedom versus oppression. The students' playful behaviour contrasts with the headmaster's attempt to impose order and control.

Education and Authority

The headmaster's refusal to listen to students and his rigid belief that "students don't tell us what to do" exposes the flaws in the education system, which is teacher-centred and oppressive, limiting the students' freedom and voice. It is this authority that motivates the students to improvise their own play instead of focusing on the prescribed one.

Ineffectiveness of Traditional Discipline 

The use of corporal punishment and violence, symbolised by the stick, critiques traditional disciplinary methods, which fail to bring about real change in the behaviour of the students.

Characterisation

The Headmaster

He is portrayed as rigid, authoritarian and unapproachable. He carries a stick, symbolising violence and a lack of empathy. His belief in traditional, oppressive discipline methods suggest that he is closed-minded, as seen in his statement that "Shakespeare is the best thing." His actions create tension among students and staff alike.

Miss Jubane

She is uncomfortable around the headmaster, indicating her vulnerability in the face of his authoritarian style. Her unease reflects the broader fear and intimidation the headmaster's leadership instills. 

Mis Jubane's generic stage name "Teacher," is symbolic. It speaks volumes about the teachers in general. Teacher is a retrogressive character who stifles creativity and innovation. It is ironic that Teacher (Miss Jubane) is a drama teacher, a discipline typically associated with fostering creativity, yet she discourages students from coming up with their own play based on their ingenuity. Teacher, thus stands as a stumbling block to education instead of being its advocate and champion. She feels threatened by the creativity of the students as she states "trouble, sir."Also, Miss Jubane is a frivolous character. She prioritises international trips at the expense of developing students' talent. 

Atmosphere 

The atmosphere is tense and oppressive. While the students create a chaotic, lively environment by playing and shouting, the headmaster's presence looms over the scene, symbolising authority and control. The environment underscores the theme of the clash between freedom and oppression within the school.

Props (The Stick)

The stick is an important prop in the scene as it symbolises violence, authority, and discipline, representing the headmaster's reliance on fear and punishment to control the students. It serves as a prolepsis to the later violent clashes in the play, suggesting the escalating consequences of oppressive leadership.

Symbolism

The Stick

The stick symbolises violence and authoritarian control. It highlights the headmaster's reliance on corporal punishment and foreshadows the violence that will escalate later in the play.

The Playing Students 

The playing students symbolise the innate freedom and joy of children. They stand in stark contrast to the oppressive nature of the education system and the headmaster's strict discipline. The clash between these two forces symbolises the broader theme of freedom versus oppression.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

AN ANALYSIS OF THE POEM "EVERY STONE THAT TURNS..." BY BVUMA

The poem opens with an air of inner turmoil. The speaker expresses disappointment at the futility of his efforts to find happiness despite his all endeavours. The motif of "every stone that turns" symbolises the chapters, experiences and phases the speaker goes through in life, all of which expose him to danger or unpleasantness.  The poem presents a sense of meaninglessness. Futility is symbolised by "an abstract atlas," representing the intangible weight of unfulfilled aspirations. The speaker feels exposed and vulnerable, as suggested by the "neon ball atop Pearl House," which hints at a precarious, unstable state of existence. The image of "a pair of high-heeled shoes" signifies a figure, possibly Yeukai, walking the empty streets in search of something vital - be it food or emotional fulfilment. The word "pecks" suggests a futile, bird-like effort to find sustenance or help, while the "still streets" emphasise the a...

COMING OF THE DRY SEASON: SHADOWS ON THE WALL

 SHADOWS ON THE WALL The story begins with a motif of shadows. This device runs through the story. This establishes a gloomy atmosphere characterised by hopelessness and dejection of the child narrator. It also emphasises the neglect and emptiness the narrator is experiencing. Even in the presence of his parents, the child feels abandoned. The family is so dysfunctional that the child finds solace in the shadows instead of the real parents. The "wall" symbolises a barrier to freedom and happiness. It represents the depressing effects of the narrator's  parents' tempestuous relationship.  The narrator has lost sense of reality after failing to find love and protection from the parents especially from the father who is abusive and callous. The real world exposes the narrator to cruelty and abuse hence the fascination on the shadows.  Through their sitting location in the hut, a huge social distance between the father and the child is reflected. The father is sitting n...

More Screen Time

More Screen Time What do you like to watch on your screen? Movies, sitcoms or comedies? Many people enjoy spending their weekends sitting on sofas or lying in bed, watching their favourite TV or online programmes on their mobile phones or televisions. Fancy Documentaries? If you enjoy shows that tell true stories about wildlife, cities or anything people don't know much about, you might love documentaries. These shows are typically  informative ,   unless  they poorly researched. However, since documentaries involve a lot of narration, some people find them dull or less engaging. Many enjoy documentaries about animals and plants, but you can also find documentaries about popular destinations, like the White Temple in Chiang Rai, Northern Thailand. The Famous White Temple - Wat Rong Khun in Chiang Rain, Thailand Laughter is The Best Medicine! Some people, however, that documentaries don't help them relax as much as they would like, so they prefer watching comedie...