Skip to main content

An Analysis of "Tomorrow's People" Scene 1

The play begins with Dalubuhle rehearsing his lines on the stage. The setting - the school hall- symbolises the power dynamics at play. The scene also introduces the central conflict, establishing the protagonist and the antagonist. The protagonist, represented by the group of students, -"tomorrow's people," embodies the values and aspirations of a new generation, frustrated by the ongoing suppression. In contrast, the antagonist, embodied by Miss Jubane, represents the stereotypical oppressive and retrogressive perspective in education, politics and society.

Alone on stage, Dalubuhle is portrayed as a champion for rebellion and the recognition of African culture. His influence in the campaign for local cultural recognition is significant as it propels the plot leading to its climax. The exposition of the play is thus characterised by tension. Dalubuhle's opening soliloquy establishes the major conflict: a cultural clash between Western and African traditions, particularly in literary works. By adapting Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, Dalubuhle positions himself as a rebellious character. His dual role - as both Dalubuhle the student and a "young black actor" - highlights the two conflicting sides he navigates. On one hand, he is expected to perform Shakespeare's play, directed by Miss Jubane; on the other hand, he must present the improvised script crafted by the students during her absence. This internal conflict propels the narrative forward generating the curiosity of the audience.

The sudden appearance of Miss Jubane disrupts the rehearsal, challenging the alterations made to the script. This interruption reflects the challenges students they face as they seek to establish their identities and advocate for the recognition of local writers. Miss Jubane's exclamation, "...not Shakespeare!" portrays her as intolerant and rigid. Her intolerance is further emphasised be her action of snatching "the script from Dalu's hand."

It is ironic that Miss Jubane plans to take her students to Scotland on a cultural tour while simultaneously forbidding them from showcasing local culture. The play thus mocks her and the education system that glorifies foreign cultures at the expense of local culture.

Dalubuhle and Miles find it absurd that they are expected to "shock Scotland" with a performance of Julius Caesar, especially as non-native English speakers. Miss Jubane, however, insists that Shakespeare is "on the syllabus and will be for years before he is removed." Her mention of the syllabus -  a formal and authoritative document -  suggests a bias towards Western writers like Shakespeare.

The exposition also explores themes of cultural appropriation and power dynamics, wherein teachers and financially affluent counties exploit those who are less privileged. Students, along with education system, struggle to promote the culture under pressure from wealthier and more powerful influence. Mis Jubane perpetuates this cultural appropriation. Ironically, as an educator, she is oblivious to the fact that promoting foreign cultures diminishes her own. She is not only an unthinking character but also a static one, lacking the autonomy and independent thought necessary for teaching literature effectively.

Miss Jubane believes that Shakespeare's artistic skills are unsurpassable. As a result, she embodies a retrogressive teaching style, glorifying the past while failing to acknowledge that Shakespeare is merely one of the many writers who have contributed to literature. She   overlooks the potential for the present generation to produce equally valuable literary works.

The lights at the beginning of the play foreshadow a new era and generation envisioned not only by the playwright but also by characters like Dalubuhle and Miles. However, the fading lights at the end of the scene signal the passage of time as the characters look forward to ushering in a new era characterised by strong cultural identity and recognition. The scene concludes on a hopeful note as the characters resolve to embark on a "fight" they must "win."

Tension exists between Western and African cultures, with Miss Jubane representing a stagnant perspective. The head of the school embodies an educational system that prioritises western literature over local African narratives. The new script symbolises a generation that values its culture and literature, while Scotland represents Western influence and acculturation. The irony lies in the purpose of the trip to Scotland, which is meant to foster cultural exchange, yet the students are expected to present a play about Shakespeare, reflecting Western culture rather than showcasing their local heritage.

This commercialised consumption of western culture falsely elevates it above African literature. The students' agitation and plea of local writers, such as Conti Mhlanga and Tsitsi Dangarembga, become central to the narrative. Additionally, the violent act of Miss Jubane grabbing the script underscores the power struggle at play, highlighting the conflict between the desire for cultural recognition and the constraints imposed by outdated educational system.

The playwright employs charactonym to highlight the themes in the play. The name Dalubuhle translates to "creator of goodness/beauty."   This name is significant in the narrative as Dalubuhle embodies the ideals of cultural pride and the promotion of African heritage. As a character, he is depicted as a champion for local culture and identity, actively rebelling against the dominance of western influences in literature and education. In contrast, the name Jubane, which means "speed," highlights Miss Jubane's role as a catalyst for the students' desire to assert their identities. On the other hand, while her name suggests agility and swift action, her actions are stagnant and restrictive, illustrating a disconnect between her name's connotation and her character's role in the play. Miles's name signifies his willingness to embark on a journey of cultural reclamation alongside Dalubuhle. Clearly, the students represent "tomorrow's people," a new generation of people purposed to change the status quo and usher in a new era.

It is important to note that the tensions introduced in the exposition foreshadow the intense political clashes  that escalate into violence, ultimately leading to the tragic deaths of some characters. The initial conflicts between Dalubuhle and Miss Jubane, centred around the script and cultural identity, are symbolic of a deeper, systematic struggle. 

Comments

Anonymous said…
Wow I love the analysis. It is on spot on, I didn't notice the symbols of Miss Jubane, Dalubuhle and Miles in the play. Now I have a clear picture and understanding of the play. Great job!
Cosmopolitan said…
You're welcome. I'm glad you're finding it helpful.

Popular posts from this blog

How to Answer Compare and Contrast Literature Questions with Success

Table of Contents  Comparing and Contrasting poems, stories or plays. The question requiring candidates to write a comparative essay is common. In can be found both in Paper 1, Comment and Appreciation, also known as the Unseens, and set-book based papers, for example papers 2, 3, 4, and 5 in the case of ZIMSEC. I'm going to outline the steps candidates should take in order to perform well on this question. When analysing two literary works like The Lift and The Accident, it's essential to use comparative and contrasting language effectively while maintaining smooth transitions between ideas. You can organise your analysis using the pendulum method (the one I recommend) or the block method, ensuring a logical and balanced approach. Here is a step-by-step guide on how to write a comparative essay. To illustrate the steps, I am going to focus on the typical exam question, " Compare and contrast  The Lift  and  The Accident." How to introduce a comparat...

Coming of the Dry Season: A Quick Guide

Table of Contents Summary of Coming of The Dry Season Studying Coming of The Dry Season?  This quick revision guide is designed to help you to grasp the key thematic concerns of the text in just a few minutes. Exploring the themes of the text will simplify your revision process and make it easy to group stories with similar themes for better understanding. You will also be able to establish the centrality of the titular story, Coming of The Dry Season and its key thematic concerns. Your understanding of the themes will also make it easy for you to understand the narrative style employed by the writer. Shadows   This story explores the theme of dysfunctional families , highlighting estranged relationships between spouses and parents and children. It also delves into issues about emotional and physical pain . The child narrator endures cruelty and child abuse within a loveless family characterised by child abuse and domestic violence . The Crow The Crow ...

How to Write Effective Topic Sentences

Table of Contents The Importance of Topic Sentences In Essay Writing  When writing a literature essay, after introducing your essay, you should then focus on unpacking the question fully in each paragraph. In order to do so effectively, you should always include a topic sentence  in each paragraph. The topic sentence, also known as the focus sentence  informs the examiner about the specific aspect of the question you are addressing in that paragraph. If your paragraph does not contain a topic sentence, it means that you want the examiner to rearrange your ideas and come up with a properly crafted paragraph. As you know, this is impossible, so, the topic sentence is a must! Why is The Topic Sentence Important The topic sentence ensures that each paragraph answers the essay question in a well structured way. The topic sentence acts as a summary of your answer for that paragraph. For example, if the question asks you to discuss the presentation of a char...